Getting Your Claim” in the U.S. Trucking Industry

 Here is a detailed professional article on the challenges and legal aspects of getting trucking claims paid in the American trucking industry — especially for owner‑operators. If you like, I can also pull together a shorter “fact sheet” or checklist for truckers.

“Getting Your Claim” in the U.S. Trucking Industry: Why So Hard & What to Do About It

Participate

Michael Mick Webster https: Blog 

By Michael Mick Webster

Syndicated investigative reporter

For many truckers — especially owner‑operators — a claim isn’t just paperwork. It can be the difference between staying in business or going under. When an accident, injury, or equipment damage knocks a rig off the road, income stops, but many costs don’t. Unfortunately, despite insurance requirements, many truckers find themselves:

• Under‑compensated
• Given the runaround
• Unable to navigate the process without expert help

The system is complex, with many moving parts — but knowledge can give you power.

Key Challenges Facing Truckers

Here are some of the major hurdles owner‑operators face when trying to get insurance or other responsible parties to pay what they’re owed:

1. Insurance Companies Avoid Fully Compensating
• Insurers often dispute claims of downtime, loss of income, or lost contracts, because these are harder to measure and verify. They may offer lower estimates or deny parts of what you claim.
• They may peg everything to “what’s reasonable,” which often works in their favor. What you deem reasonable may be treated as excessive.
2. Runarounds & Delays
• Insurance adjusters might delay obtaining or reviewing documents.
• They may ask for more than once for similar or overlapping documentation.
• Delays might be due to workload, inadequate staffing, or “waiting for something more definitive” — but the effect is that your rig sits idle longer, and expenses keep piling up.
3. Complexity of the Claim Process
• Trucking claims often go beyond just “car damage.” They can include physical damage, cargo loss, personal injury (or occupational accident), general liability, non‑trucking liability (when you’re off‑dispatch), and downtime / business interruption. Each has its own rules and insurers.
• Proof of income / lost revenue is tricky. You need detailed records of what your business was earning or could have earned, contracts you missed, typical revenue per day, etc.
4. “Duty to Mitigate” Arguments
• Insurers will often argue you could have mitigated your losses (e.g. rented a truck, repaired faster, used alternate equipment) and thus reduce your claim. If you didn’t do what they consider “reasonable,” they can reduce pay‑out.
• But many owner‑operators can’t afford to rent replacement equipment; many specialty rigs or trailers are hard to substitute; sometimes licensing, availability, or other constraints prevent mitigation.
5. Coverage Gaps & Limitations
• Some policies don’t include downtime, occupational accident, or income replacement unless added as endorsements or separate policies. If you don’t have them in your policy, you may have no recourse.
• Deductibles, coverage limits, exclusions (e.g. certain causes, locations, types of use) may bite you if you don’t understand them.
6. Legal / State Differences
• Rules vary state to state. Statutes of limitations, allowable evidence, what counts as “business expenses,” how courts treat “loss of use” or “business interruption” differ.
• Owner‑operators working under lease vs. own authority have different legal responsibilities and contractual relationships that affect claims.

What “Downtime Claims” Are & Why They Matter

• “Downtime” (also called “loss of use”, “lost income/revenue”, or “business interruption”) refers to the period your truck (or business) is not earning due to damage from an accident or other covered incident. McGee Lerer Ogrin+4Eckert & Associates, P.A.+4Overdrive+4
• During that time, fixed costs still come due: truck payments, insurance, leasing, permits, maintenance, sometimes wages if you have employees. The gap between income that would have come in and what you receive (if anything) is what you’re trying to recover. Eckert & Associates, P.A.+2Eckert & Associates, P.A.+2
• Because “downtime” is not visible (not a physical damage per se), it is one of the most disputed parts of claims. Insurers are often skeptical of how much you “really lost,” or how long the downtime should be.

The Legal / Insurance Tools Available

To get what you deserve, you must know what protections and legal tools exist. Some of these are insurance coverages; others are legal principles.

1. Insurance Coverages
• Occupational Accident Insurance — for owner‑operators or contractors; covers medical expenses and disability income when injured on the job. Zurich North America+1
• Physical Damage — covers damage to the truck/trailer from collisions, theft, fire, etc. Vatic Insurance+1
• Motor Truck Cargo Insurance — for freight you are hauling. If cargo is damaged or lost, this coverage may apply. Vatic Insurance+1
• Non‑Trucking Liability / Non‑Trucking Use — for periods when you’re not under dispatch or not hauling, but still operating the truck. Sentry Insurance+2Vatic Insurance+2
• Downtime & Loss of Income / Business Interruption Endorsements — sometimes optional add‑ons; very valuable. Eckert & Associates, P.A.+3Vatic Insurance+3Overdrive+3
• Rental/Reimbursement — when you must rent replacement equipment to keep working. If available, this can reduce “lost days.” Vatic Insurance+1
2. Legal Remedies
• If someone else is at fault (another driver, third party), their insurance may be required to pay your losses. You may need to pursue a claim against the at‑fault party. McGee Lerer Ogrin+1
• If insurer is acting in “bad faith” (e.g. unreasonable delays, denying without basis, misrepresenting coverage) you may have legal claims (depending on state law) over and above what the policy promises.
• Statutory rights to certain coverages or to have certain coverage minimums under FMCSA or state laws. For instance, minimum liability required for interstate trucking. Sentry Insurance+2OOIDA+2

Why a Lawyer (Experienced in Trucking / Downtime Claims) Is Often Essential

Because of all the complexities listed above, having good legal help can make a major difference. Here’s what a lawyer with trucking claims experience can do:

• Help compile all the necessary documentation: income records, contracts, logs of expenses, repair estimates.
• Ensure timelines are met (statutes of limitation, filing deadlines).
• Push back when insurers try to deny or reduce claims via “mitigation” arguments or technicalities.
• Handle negotiations, demand letters, possibly litigation if needed.
• Evaluate potential for higher damages (e.g. punitive, if bad faith) or extra costs.

Steps to Protect Yourself and Strengthen Your Claim

To maximize your chance of fair compensation, truckers—owner‑operators especially—should take proactive steps before and after an adverse event:

1. Before an incident
• Make sure your insurance covers downtime, loss of income, occupational accident, etc.; get endorsements as needed.
• Keep excellent business records: past revenues, contracts, load assignments, cancelled loads, fixed business costs, equipment leases, insurance, maintenance, etc.
• Photograph and document your rig well; ensure maintenance logs are up to date.
2. When an incident occurs
• Report immediately to all relevant parties (insurer, police, FMCSA if required).
• Document damage thoroughly: photos, repair estimates, police or incident reports.
• Track all days the truck is idle; log all fixed costs that continue.
3. During the claim process
• Be clear, organized, consistent in what you claim. Provide good proof (past income, contracts lost, etc.).
• Don’t accept low‑ball offers without asking why; don’t sign anything waiving rights unless you understand.
• Keep evidence of repairs, quotes, delays, rental quotes if you attempted or needed replacement.
4. If hit obstacles
• Get legal representation. Lawyers versed in trucking downtime claims know the tactics insurers use, and how to press back.
• Consider involving experts (accountants, appraisers) to help quantify losses.

Real Consequences of Losing Out

• Owner‑operators may lose income they cannot recover, yet still have to pay fixed costs. Loan payments, insurance premiums, permits, lease expenses—these don’t stop just because work stopped.
• Downtime can ripple: losing trust with brokers, losing contracts, inability to cover house or truck payments can push many into bankruptcy or force them off the road.
• Delays in payment or under‑payment can create cash flow crises. Many owner‑operators live close to the margin.

Why Owner‑Operators Deserve More Attention

• They are small business owners: in many ways, risks and responsibilities are entirely on them. Unlike fleet drivers, owner‑operators often carry most of their own costs and risks.
• They are essential to the freight infrastructure: without owner‑operators, many loads don’t get delivered. Yet, they often don’t have the negotiating leverage of large carriers.
• The law often expects them to carry more burdens (maintenance, insurance, authority) and pay the costs upfront, yet compensation in claims often lags or is disputed.

Getting a trucking claim paid fairly — especially one involving loss of income or downtime — is seldom easy. The owner/operator’s burden is heavy. But it isn’t hopeless. With the right insurance coverages in place, rigorous documentation, and (often) strong legal representation, truckers can significantly improve their chances of being made whole.

No trucker should lose income because their rig is sidelined through no fault of their own. And though the system may be stacked against them in many ways, understanding your rights, preparing ahead, and enforcing them can shift the balance.