Rare Backwardation in the Silver Market — what it signals for physical demand & price structure”
By Syndicated investigative reporter, Michael Mick Webster
In recent months, the global physical silver market has exhibited one of the most striking structural anomalies in the history of the metal: backwardation.
What is backwardation?
In most futures markets (including precious metals), the normal state is contango: the futures price is higher than the spot/physical price, reflecting storage & insurance costs + time value of money. Suisse Gold+2Hero Bullion+2
By contrast, backwardation occurs when spot > futures — buyers are willing to pay more now for immediate delivery than for the same metal at a later date. Metals Edge+1
Why is backwardation showing up in silver?
Some of the key drivers behind this unusual inversion in 2025 include:
- Physical supply stress / inventory draw‑downs — e.g., major vault withdrawals, tight shipping/logistics. InProved+2Metal News+2
- Strong immediate demand for physical metal — industrial (solar panels, electronics), investment coins/bars, safe‑haven flows. Metals Edge+1
- Paper market vs. physical market disconnect — when futures contracts and deliverable physical metal diverge, the premium for physical delivery rises. GoldSeek News
- Geopolitical/trade/monetary stresses that push demand for real assets rather than promises of future delivery. Metals Edge
What are the recent signs?
- The December 2025 silver futures contract (COMEX) was trading more than US$2 lower than the LBMA spot price. Metal News+2InProved+2
- Some refiners report actual shipping times of ~50 days to get metal from U.S. to London unless air‑freighted at high cost. Metal News
- Elevated lease/borrowing rates for physical silver (one‑month lease rates reportedly hitting ~30% +). Metals Edge+1
- Analysts now point to backwardation as a warning signal of physical market dysfunction, not just a technical curiosity. Discovery Alert
Why does this matter to investors / industrial users?
- For investors: Backwardation can be a bullish indicator — it means “I need it now” rather than “I’ll lock it in later.” The usual cost‑carry (storage, insurance) is being overwhelmed by immediate demand.
- For industrial users: It signals tighter deliverable supply, which can drive up premiums for immediate delivery / physical bar/coin products, lead times lengthening, and increased lead‑time risk.
- For futures market participants: Short positions can become vulnerable if there isn’t enough metal for delivery; arbitrage becomes harder; the normal relationship between spot and futures breaks down.
- For market structure watchers: It underscores how physical metal markets (and the difference between paper/futures and physical) can diverge — something often glossed over in mainstream commentary.
Outlook & caveats
- While backwardation is rare for precious metals like gold and silver (especially gold) given the size of global inventories, it is occurring in silver right now, which makes it noteworthy. GoldBroker+1
- That said, backwardation does not guarantee a sustained rally — it means pressure exists in the physical market now. If supply catches up (or demand softens), conditions can revert.
- Investors should also remember that high premiums, thin physical liquidity, and logistical/hands‑on risks (storage, delivery) can increase transaction costs.
- From a timing perspective, backwardation may precede sharp price moves — but it’s not a signal for when exactly that move happens.
Key takeaway
For those watching the precious‑metals space, the current backwardation in silver is a red flag — or perhaps a green flag, depending on your perspective — signaling that physical supply/demand is under significant stress, and that the “paper vs physical” gap is widening. It’s a structural cue to go beneath headline price moves and ask: Are we dealing with a normal metals market, or one where deliverable metal is being hoarded, delayed, or drawn down faster than expected?
Recent precious‑metals market news
Bank of America now sees $65 silver, as price spike reduces London market to a 'state of seizure.'
Silverines cash in on a dysfunctional market
Why the silver squeeze is finally about to end, analyst says
Article 2: “What Backwardation in Gold & Silver Means for Portfolio Strategy”
As bullion markets soar to new highs — particularly for silver — the phenomenon of backwardation in both the gold and silver markets is drawing increasing attention from investors, analysts and commodity strategists.
Setting the scene
- The price of gold recently breached all‑time highs, driven by macro factors such as inflation concerns, safe‑haven demand, weak U.S. dollar, and rate‑cut expectations. AP News+1
- Silver has out‑paced gold in many respects this year — fueled not only by monetary/investor demand, but also by industrial demand (electronics, solar) and tight physical supply. MarketWatch+1
- Amid this, backwardation has appeared — particularly in silver — meaning the spot price is higher than futures, which is unusual in these large, liquid metals markets.
Why it matters for gold AND silver
By Michael Mick Webster
Gold
- While backwardation in gold has been very rare historically, its appearance would signal extreme stress in the physical market (e.g., inventory shortages, delivery issues, very high demand for immediate metal) rather than just speculative interest. GoldBroker+1
- That said, gold’s larger global supply, central‑bank holdings and reserve status mean it is less likely to exhibit persistent backwardation — but when it does, it may point to a significant underlying shift.
Silver
- The still‑relatively smaller market size of silver, larger industrial component of demand, and lower global relative inventories (compared to gold) make it more prone to backwardation. Metals Edge+1
- The current backwardation in silver is not just technical; it reflects deliverability issues, physical metal scarcity (or unwillingness to part with it), and logistical/transport constraints. For example: shipping delays, high premiums for immediate bars/coins. Metal News+1
What this means for portfolio strategy
- Consider physical allocation – When spot metal commands a premium over futures, it may underscore the value of holding actual metal (bars/coins/vaulted) rather than relying solely on paper/futures or ETF representations of metal.
- Mind liquidity and delivery risk – Markets in backwardation may see tighter liquidity, higher storage/insurance/transport premiums, and delivery delays. Be sure you understand where you hold and how you can access/exit your position.
- Don’t treat it purely as a normal contango commodity play – The traditional cost‑carry models (buy now, hold until futures, etc.) may not apply. The motivations of buyers are immediate possession rather than later receipt.
- Watch for signals of relief or reversal – If supply chains ease, physical metal flows increase, or demand softens, the backwardation may unwind (futures rise relative to spot) and there could be a retracement.
- Differentiate between gold and silver dynamics – While both are precious metals, their market drivers differ significantly. Silver has the added dimension of industrial demand and thus may react differently to backwardation signals.
- Build scenario‑thinking into risk models – A backwardated market may imply a heightened risk of sharp upward moves (if supply remains constrained) or sharp corrections (if the paper market catches up). Having multiple outcome scenarios is prudent.
Bottom line
Backwardation in the precious metals space is a structural signal — a yellow (or even red) flag — not just a headline for traders. It suggests that physical metal now may be more valuable than promises of metal later.
If you are an investor, industrial user, or portfolio manager with exposure to gold or silver, this is a moment to ask:
- Am I positioned for “metal now” or “metal later”?
- What is the gap between paper exposure (futures/ETFs) and real, deliverable metal?
- What might happen if physical supply remains constrained while demand persists or increases?
In short: backwardation is not everyday; when it happens in gold & silver, it deserves attention.
No comments:
Post a Comment